Image
The Hon. Yadhira Gonzalez-Taylor ’99

The Hon. Yadhira Gonzalez-Taylor ’99: From Troubled Childhood to Supervising Judge

Current Role: Supervising Judge, Criminal Court of the City of New York, Bronx County
Degrees from John Jay: B.S. in Criminal Justice and M.A. in Deviancy Studies 
Law School: J.D. from New York Law School (2002)
Military Rank/Job: Specialist, Military Police, U.S. Army Reserve (1992­–1998)
Hometown: Bronx, NY; Puerto Rico

What was life like before John Jay? 
I’m a first-generation everything—first in my entire family to go to college, get a master’s degree, and a law degree. My mom had a high school diploma and my father earned his high school diploma in prison. I grew up between the Bronx and Puerto Rico. I was born in the Bronx—Spanish is my first language—and moved to Puerto Rico when I was very young. I truly think of myself as a Bronx-Puerto Rico hybrid because there were a lot of moves back and forth from the two places. The moves were due in part to my father being incarcerated when I was two years old for a crime he committed in the Bronx. My mother needed support, so she sent me to Puerto Rico to live with my grandparents. That way, my mother could stay behind in New York to work, and my grandparents could help with childcare. 

Unfortunately, I can’t say that my upbringing was functional. There were a lot of challenges with poverty, food insecurity, domestic violence, and repeated incarcerations. My father struggled with alcoholism and mental illness. I’d go to my grandparents in Puerto Rico to get away from that environment, but then I faced grandparents who were a little too strict, and I came back to New York. 

The stress from my home life made it hard to focus in high school and I graduated with a 69 percent average. When I enthusiastically went to my high school counselor, with a CUNY application in hand, she was like, “Don’t bother, your grades are horrible.” She didn't even suggest stenography or secretary school. She ended the conversation with, “You might as well just get a job.” Since no one in my family was well-versed in education or had access to educational resources, I decided to work for a bank. I could type really fast, so I got a job at JP Morgan right after I graduated. 

While I was there, I met this young man who kept asking me, “Why aren’t you going to school?” When I shared my life story with him, he recommended that I go to a community college. So, I applied to BMCC (Borough of Manhattan Community College) and they accepted me. 

By then, my life was a lot more stable for one main reason: My father was out of our lives. My parents separated when I was 17, but by the time I was 19, he was stalking my mom. There was this horrible pattern of stalking where he’d follow her everywhere, including her job. She tried to get orders of protection from family court, but they were not effective. Ultimately, early one morning, he tracked her to our new home in Patterson, New Jersey. He approached her with a gun and said, “You know, you have to take me back or I’m gonna kill you.” A neighbor came out to see what was going on and my father shot the neighbor, who almost died. It was a very traumatic experience for everyone in my family—especially my 10-year-old brother who witnessed the entire event. Once my father was arrested and out of our lives for good, I could finally focus on my life and studies.

At BMCC, I started to do really well. I was getting A’s and B’s and learned that I could do the work. In high school I felt dumb, especially after hearing my counselor say I wasn’t good enough to go to college. At BMCC, I started to see myself as smart and I thought about pursuing a career in criminal justice, possibly becoming a police officer. 

Why John Jay? 
While at BMCC, I learned more about John Jay. I liked that it was geared toward police officers and firefighters. John Jay was known all over the world for its criminal justice program and it was the place to be if you wanted to study criminal justice. Understanding the power of the school’s reputation, I thought to myself, If I’m gonna become a cop, I’m going to John Jay. Since I was doing so well at BMCC, I decided to transfer to John Jay after one year. What’s interesting is that the young man who suggested that I go to community college ended up going to John Jay also. His name is Kingsley Taylor ’22. He became an FDNY firefighter and we got married at City Hall. Now, we have three children together. 

What inspired you to pursue a legal career? 
Honestly, I had to pivot. In my mind, I was all set to become a police officer. I had even joined the military during that period of time as an MP (military police) in the U.S. Army Reserve so that I could get experience in the field. However, after I took the police exam and they called me to join the NYPD, I found out that I was pregnant with Kingsley’s baby. They explained that I couldn’t go through the process of going to the academy while pregnant, but I could revisit the idea after I had the baby. After I gave birth, I took the exam again and scored really well, but my weight was too high for their requirement. It just wasn’t working out for me to become a police officer, but thinking about the experiences with my dad, and growing up in a community impacted by the crack epidemic, I knew I wanted to work with victims, provide public safety, and be an enforcer of the rules. That’s what drove me to the legal field. I decided, If I can’t be a cop, then I’ll be a prosecutor. 

Another reason why I wanted to become a prosecutor was watching what my mother went through with the legal system. After the shooting, I sat through my dad’s trial. I delivered a victim impact statement on behalf of my mom and I observed how she was treated in the courtroom. The defense attorney even tried to suggest that the neighbor, who was just an innocent person who lived in the building, was my mom’s lover—which was not true. Seeing all of that made me want to help victims, prepare for a trial, fight for the truth, and hold people accountable. The prosecutor on the case did a great job and I wanted to be like him. 

How did John Jay influence your career path? 
The academic aspect of John Jay was great. I really learned everything I needed to know about the criminal justice system to prepare me to work in this system for the last 23 and a half years. I had a professor, Richard Wolf, who taught a corrections master’s-degree-level course. One day he asked if anyone was interested in doing an internship that involved a lot of data entry. Even as a student-parent, I knew I could handle the work because that’s what I did before I went to college. That internship gave me real-life, hands-on, practical learning outside of an academic setting. I told Professor Wolf, who was a lawyer himself, about my desire to go to law school and he gave me fantastic advice on how to shape my personal statement and study for the LSAT. He repeatedly looked over my essay, gave me important suggestions, and told me, “You’re going to be a great lawyer someday.” The fact that he had a full-time job at the New York City Board of Correction and a part-time job as an adjunct at John Jay, but he still found time to help me really meant a lot. 

What was your path to the bench?
I’m the type of person who just goes with the flow. I just manage to navigate life and figure it out as I go. A lot of people coming out of law school will say, I’m going to become a judge in 10 years. I never thought that and I didn’t aspire to become a judge when I was an attorney. I worked at the DA’s office for almost four years. It was tough because I had two little kids at home and a husband who was a fireman. That made me look for something that was more conducive to a work-life balance. So, I went from the DA’s office to the Police Department (NYPD) and then the Department of Education (DOE). All of these moves were designed to accommodate my life and my family. At the Police Department, I dealt with disciplinary matters, and at the DOE I was a hearing officer for the superintendent’s office doing disciplinary hearings for kids that got suspended. It was my job as a hearing officer that helped me develop that muscle of being able to put myself in the middle and not be an advocate for either side. 

I have a good friend who I met at the DOE and she always said to me, “You should think about becoming a judge. You’ve been a hearing officer, why not take that skill set and put it to use for the community at large?” At first, I didn’t think it was for me. Then others started to mention it and I started to listen. I researched, went to different workshops, and connected with judges for mentorship. Then I just went for it.

Looking back to your life and career, what makes you the proudest? 
I’m proudest of the fact that I survived. I sometimes struggle with feeling proud about that, but it’s the truth. I was able to get through all of those challenges and achieve as much as I did despite the odds.